
By: James Robinson (Writer), Tom Grummett (Penciller), Tom Palmer (Inker), Jim Charalampidis (Color Artist), VC’s Clayton Cowles (Letterer), Greg Land, Jay Leisten and Nolan Woodard (Cover Artists)
The Story: If happy ever after did exist, Sue would still be holding Valeria like this…
The Review: The cover features art by Greg Land, who should remember (like many, many artists) that children’s faces should not look like adults’ with simply bigger heads. In fact, Valeria on the cover looks like her features are floating over the head, as if they are separate elements selected on a layer and resized accordingly. Tom Grummett handles the art inside the book, and the depictions of characters are overall much better. For example, take a look at Valeria’s pronouncement “No, Mom. I’m fine where I am.” Her proportions are quite childlike here, and the bird’s-eye perspective captures her vulnerability yet quiet confidence perfectly.
The results are a bit inconsistent, however, with other panels looking quite monstrous. Perhaps that was the intent? I’m thinking of the time it’s revealed that she was using a Val-bot for the majority of the conversation with her mother. Nevertheless, Grummett is always a favorite of mine, someone who can bring very bright, solidly-realized figures and have them interact with drama and intensity. There’s an extended fight scene with the Invisible Woman versus pretty much all of Latveria, and it’s climatic and vibrant. Which, again, is the point, since it adds so much pathos to little Valeria who reaches out to Sue/the reader in a panel of debris, and later who looks up in an isolated establishing layout and declares she’s “scared” of her own mom.
That’s the emotional climax of the story, a story filled with complex emotion. To put it into context, this story takes place between the issues as if this were issue number 11. Remember when Annuals were extra stories that weren’t necessary to understand the ongoing plots of the main series? Yeah, this is not one of them. To fully experience the ongoing storyline, you’ll need this one. There was a time when Marvel would forgo publishing an annual and simply publish a 13th issue of the ongoing series for the calendar year. Here, that’s what they’re doing; they’re just giving you 30 pages of art (counting double-page spreads) and labeling it “annual” (and charging $4.99.)
But this is not a review of Marvel’s publishing practices. Let’s talk about the story, which is quite effective. I am very happy of how the Invisible Woman handles herself here. To be a mother, she’s ready to stand up, quite boldly and without her characteristic stealth, to Dr. Doom, single-handedly. She shows a degree of control over her power that once again reinforces that she’s the one of the strongest heroes of the Marvel Universe. But the best moment, for me, is when she tells her daughter that “no, you’re not” staying with Doom. It’s in contrast to the leeway she might have given the hyper-intelligent three-year old, but it acknowledges the fact that she’s the mom, and there’s more rational ways of handling the situation. True, it quickly degenerates into a fight with the army of Latveria, and it ultimately does not become the final word as Valeria does, in fact, stay with Doom, but it’s the most appropriate and logical response a parent should give, and there’s no plot-induced-stupidity here.
I’d argue that Sue ultimately realizes that she became more Doom-like than Doom, and that’s what causes her to leave Valeria with him at the end. Yes, it’s gut-wrenching to hear that Valeria is afraid of her own mother (thanks again to such expressive art from Grummett), but really Sue’s argument that, well, she IS the mother should still be quite valid. No, something happened that scared Sue, that causes her to make that choice.
What I’m not such a fan of is that this “something” could be some other kind of force, referred to here by Doom as “Malice.” I came into comics later than this notorious storyline, but as far as I remember, there was never a separate entity of Malice within Sue that created that identity for her, and the whole thing seems to smell like a Dark Phoenix kind of thing. You know, a woman can’t be powerful in her own right without somehow being “evil” or possessed. If we go down this route, I’ll be disappointed. There’s enough going on in the FF’s storyline that this would be a needless overcomplication.
The Bottom Line: The art here is classic in sensibility and raw in emotion. Sue makes an awesome show of power as a mother and as a hero, but ultimately scares herself and perhaps sets up the re-hashing of a character “development” that should be left in the past. This storyline in some ways feels like it’s ticking a checklist item for a story point that should have been in the main series, and, when combined with the fact the Future Foundation has been sidelined, the regular title can continue without any pesky kids featured in it whatsoever.
The Grade: B
-Danny Wall
Grade
Conclusion