By: Clay McLeod Chapman (Writer), Elia Bonetti (Penciller), Veronica Gandini (Color Artist), VC’s Clayton Cowles (Letterer), Garry Brown (Cover Artist)

The Story: “I was a teenage spider-man! Literally.”

The Review: The cover is a wonderful throwback to the horror comic books of the 1950s and the precursor to the Timely/Marvel publishing line, and it’s also unlike any of the Edge of Spider-Verse covers we’ve seen. All of which can also be said of the story inside.

Also unlike any of the Edge series we’ve had so far, this issue tells us an origin story from start to finish, rather than including it in exposition or a flashback. This Spider-Man (or rather, as I wish he were called, Man-Spider) is Patton Parnel, and although there are some superficial resemblances to the familiar Peter Parker story, almost every element is somehow twisted, creating a quite disturbing horror comic from plot, to character, to tone.    

The artwork here is equally effective. Most of the time, Parnel is depicted as without much emotion at all. It helps reinforce his cold, scientific way of approaching the world, and it makes him already “inhuman” before he ever transforms into a literal monster. It also helps sell the transformation, as the cold face of Parnel switches suddenly into more sinister expressions and, finally, into the Man-Spider. The setting is used just as well. There’s rarely been as effective a splash page turn as when Sara Jane runs into the wrong room and we see the veritable torture chamber of Parnel’s nest.

There’s a lot going on here, to be sure, and so perhaps the story relies on pretty standard tropes more than it should. And there’s more than a few jumps in logic to make those tropes work, such as Sara Jane suddenly taking *this moment* to reach out to Parnel for reasons never really explained. Some of those leaps also make it into the artwork as well. For some reason, we get a panel of blood cells interrupting our dialogue, but it never does anything like that again nor provides any caption, context. Sara Jane is seen crying as Parnel is beat by Uncle Ted, with no reason to connect those two images. And of course there’s the final panel, which dutifully brings us yet another horror cliché, but in this case it’s a bit reminiscent of the last panel of the previous issue, which ended with a sci-fi version of the same cliché.

What I found most disturbing of all was reading about a character that I love but knowing we’re reading about the villain, the monster. There really wasn’t anything redeeming about him, nor did he ever really question his choices or weigh his options, proving to be a psychopath from the very beginning. In that case, does Morlun’s appearance at the end, in the most extended sequence we have had of him so far, signal that he’s some kind of hero? Does Morlun’s presence help cull the universes of dangerous Man-Spiders? That’s an intriguing twist, but sadly, that’s my own spin as Morlun does little more than out-monster the monster.    

The Bottom Line: This story has a definite goal in twisting our familiar story into one of horror, and it does so quite effectively. It’s not a story I’d naturally gravitate to, but I give credit where credit is due. Some attention is given to hint at the larger story regarding totem energy, but it holds its own as a creepy, disturbing tale.

The Grade: B

-Danny Wall

Other Tidbits:
— All the Edge of Spider-Verses seem to have a definitive genre they are trying to emulate. We’ve had Noir, Traditional Superhero, Sci-Fi Thriller, and now Horror. I think we might run out of issues before we get to Shakespearean Farce, but maybe there are some more we can think of. 80s Sitcom? Old West? Medieval legend? Chinese opera? My Little Spider: Responsibility is Magic?

Grade

Conclusion