
By: Geoff Johns (story), Scott Kolins (art), Andrew Dalhouse (colors)
The Story: Who knew that Luthor’s preferred thank-you gift is flowers?
The Review: In my line of work, the problem of chronic criminal behavior and its causes comes up quite a lot. It’s relatively easy to feel compassion for the culprits when you examine the difficulties they live with and their troubled upbringing, a lot harder when they screw up an opportunity to break the cycle. But isn’t it human nature to stick to what you know, even if it’s detrimental? I’m not talking about innate evil, but rather the ingrained feeling that you don’t deserve to have it good.
That’s the conflict you can see in Lenny Snart (a.k.a. Captain Cold) right now as he simultaneously revels in his newfound luxury and assures the Rogues his troublemaking days aren’t over. From any rational standpoint, it’s crazy that he’s planning to go back to a life of crime when he can have a pretty awesome life on the straight—or somewhat straight, this being Lex Luthor and all. But his dream of the Flash and his father accusing him of never amounting to anything indicates that is how he actually feels about himself, and the promise he makes to Mirror Master that this will be “the biggest job of our lives” suggests a strict sense of loyalty that won’t allow him to rise up on his own.
Luthor doesn’t have these same hang-ups. The only thing that stops Luthor from true greatness is Luthor, something we see from his respective conversations with Clark, Bruce, and Diana. Of all these one-on-ones, the most revelatory comes from Diana, a smart choice on Johns part that shows he’s finally getting how to write her. Unlike the dubious Clark and the openly hostile Bruce, Diana lacks personal animosity towards Luthor and more readily gives him the benefit of the doubt. As she and Luthor help provide aid to a needy village, she acknowledges the good he’s done, but asks, “[W]hy have you? Can you answer that question honestly without the Lasso?”
A pause. “Often to deflect attention away from another issue Lexcorp might be having. For public image. Tax write-offs. Ultimately, to build money and power.”
What follows is a sappy but perhaps necessary scene where Luthor experiences true, innocent gratitude for the first time. No one’s naïve enough to believe this is a life-changing moment, but the fact the keeps the little girl’s gift on his desk suggests he’s more affected by the experience than Clark and Bruce would give him credit for. It’d be interesting if Johns can transform Luthor into an antihero by the end of this storyline—Luthor’s too valuable an antagonist to go all the way. Why not? Johns did the same for Sinestro, which only made him that much more compelling a character. The signs for Luthor remain ambiguous, however, what with the end-of-issue twist that he’s partnered with a figure even more untrustworthy and callous than he is.
Meanwhile, the question of where Jessica Cruz will land on the hero-villain divide still stands. Right now, she’s getting very good support from Barry, the most accessible of Leaguers,* but the power in her hands is inherently corrupting. She may be able to contain it, but it’s doubtful she can change it, which is why there’s something ominous to her decision not to remove the ring, but rather to learn how to use it. Let’s hope Johns defeats the suggestion that Jessica will give in to the ring’s evil influence. We’ve already had one Latina turn out to be the baddie; having two will just be racial stereotyping.
Another Kolins issue. I’ve made my prejudices about his art fairly clear and he doesn’t offer much reason for me to change my mind in this issue. To be fair, his style, with its fine lines and emphasis on movement, is vaguely reminiscent of John Romita Jr.’s work, but it’s also messier, filled with extraneous lines that get in the story’s way and which nearly blend together once Dalhouse’s colors are applied. Kolins also doesn’t have Romita’s emotional subtlety, so you end up with a Jessica Cruz whose psychotic traits are on full display without the fear and anxiety to soften them.
Conclusion: The art leaves much to be desired, but the story runs smoothly and hints at growing complexities among the new Leaguers.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * If this is intended to bring back the usual Flash-Green Lantern pairing with a twist, I’m all for it.
– How about that title page image of Superman hovering in midair with his legs and arms splayed apart as if some invisible person just kicked him in the nuts? Is that not the most awkward pose ever?
Grade
Conclusion