I admit it; I love me some superhuman throw-downs, as mighty marvelous titans of power clash in tremendous displays of power. And thankfully almost every page here has some crazy flash of energy, swirling circles of mental thrall, cosmic blasts, energized lances, or just an ominous, looming gigantic figure of pure evil/hatred. This is a big budget blockbuster of a comicbook, so on that level it’s epic, cool, and flashy.

Which is not to say, unfortunately, that all is well with other elements of a good comicbook. The opening sequence, and the very last page, are framed with a logo, which is disappointing in its layout. It forces the art to be more compact and distracts from a natural, immersive reading experience. The opening sequence, too, is full of double-page spreads (which is not preferable when reading on a tablet but I’m sure is nicely dramatic for someone reading it in book form) that are feel cramped with an overuse of skinny panels that rely on a lot of dialogue to establish the setting/development.

There’s a lot going on, which means the art is not really allowed to slow down a bit. I’d rather there’d be more examples such as when the Avengers are regrouping in the middle of the issue, and Wasp is allowed to muse on the nature of being a hero and the loss she experienced in the recent Uncanny Avengers’ story. The pacing is effective, but the colors do nothing to notice there’s a mood shift here, and despite some layout choices to show her expressions, the art doesn’t carry much emotion. In fact, overall I would have preferred a more “softer” artist than Adam Kubert, whose figures are too scratchily rendered, too blocky and stiff, to really be engaging. Hey, there was one dramatic panel with Magneto reaching out, with hands all purply-glowing, but when Cyclops makes a bold move to save his brother Havok, there’s very little drama about it at all, as if the most dramatic moment was in-between the panels. There’s just too much of a cast and to grand of a scale here for his strengths.

The storyline, despite its epicness, actually centers around relatively few characters, and mostly around those already featured in the recent Uncanny Avengers #25 — Magneto, Scarlet Witch, Rogue, and Havok. There’s also a bit of Wasp and Iron Man thrown in there, too, which leaves the remaining cast of dozens to be reduced to quips and token soundbites. It’s quite a study in extremes– with heavy-handed pathos for those in focus and interchangeable/uncharacteristic snippets for others. I appreciate Rogue’s connection to Professor X’s spirit, but I have a hard time believing in Black Widow’s concern over the Real Housewives. (Yes, I understand she’s being sarcastic, but it still feels weird that the Widow would even deign to acknowledge it, when you could have switched the dialogue with Hawkeye for a better delivery.) For every use of something like Nightcrawler showing himself to be the true heart of the X-Men, there’s something like Colossus calling Corsair’s “spaceman spiff dance… fabulous.” Well, actually, there’s a lot of cameos with people that don’t really say anything, but in some cases maybe it’s preferable?

One of the potential game-changing moments is the Red Onslaught’s revelation that Tony Stark has been subtly manipulated by the Red Skull, with a “little telepathic influence” to build Sentinels out of adamantium. This, despite the fact that Tony Stark just this very issue has shown to be paranoid enough to have anti-telepathic hardware in his armor and is capable of using that to create anti-telepathic areas in his buildings. It’s disruptive to Tony Stark’s position within the Marvel universe, obviously, as it quite explicitly resurrects his role in Marvel’s Civil War story (circa 2006) but also reminds me of something even more heinous, the Avengers’ Crossing storyline (1995).       

 

-Danny Wall

Grade

B-

Conclusion

The stakes are raised as heroes gather to face an overwhelmingly powerful foe. Appropriately, this means a lot of displays of heroic and villainous power, although it does mean some of our characters are reduced to simply cameos or lame soundbites. Sometimes the story doesn't seem to take itself seriously, with only token acknowledgement or even illogical actions/dialogue from various Marvel series, since it saves its most important moments from events and situations from the Uncanny Avengers. Except for Iron Man; his revelations are completely out of left field, or at least from a storyline eight years ago. Other tidbits: -- Plantman's redesign is quite nice, and he seems more appropriately powered to face a team of Avengers. It's even consistent with his one-time development into Blackheath. -- Does Sunfire's costume change when he's "flamed on," so he can switch back to his regular reds-and-whites? -- When did Red Skull capture Quentin Quire, Cyclops, and Genesis, who all appear in different titles, and locations, anyway? -- Please don't put a dream sequence in the middle of a double-page spread that's not a dream sequence. -- Why does Ahab's spear pass through Evan but only attach its tip to Cyclops' upper arm? -- Thor has his axe, but isn't "disarmed" as his recent appearance in his own title, although Steve Rogers remains aged and Sam Wilson is Captain America. Timeline, anyone? -- I'm not sure I'm going to have the budget for this if it's truly a weekly series.