It has all the things to like from #1, just more! Of course, it has all the things we didn’t like, too, but let’s focus on what’s cool about comics, right? For example, that last page splash. Now that’s just fun.

The central character here is Iron Man, which is both a strength and a weakness, or an example of one of those “liked/didn’t like” things I mentioned above. We hear much of the narration from his point of view, which includes a lot of self-apologetic hand-wringing. Of course, this only works if you trust in Tony Start in the first place and believe him to be a paragon of heroic virtue. He isn’t (this is Marvel Comics of course, with feet-of-clay heroes), and in fact a lot of the exposition in the beginning gives Stark a lot of backstory better fit for a supervillain. By the same token, you really have to buy into the whole “Tony Stark is a genius” premise in the first place, because we’re told these Sentinels are such a big deal precisely because Tony Stark sort-of-kind-of built them. (See? That was your problem, Bolivar Trask. You just aren’t Tony Stark.)

So, I’m sorry if I don’t feel a lot of sympathy for Iron Man. I’m almost ready to side with Magneto, who displays almost a one-note character whose superpower is cutting banter against Stark and almost becomes a bit too much. There’s a bit of redemption possible for Stark, as he not only is given opportunity to lead a (ultimately doomed) salvo against the Red Onslaught, but also to give a bit of third quarter rallying speech. I love this kind of stuff, as I follow comics precisely because I want to experience what’s like to be a hero, but I was a bit underwhelmed by his speech. So it all all comes down to “just so long as we do it”? That’s… really unsatisfying. I hope Stark hires someone else for motivating personnel at his company.

The other character moments are small, by comparison, like little parachute drops of characterizations in a panel here or there. Gone are the forced jokes, thankfully, and instead there’s a bit more natural dialogue, including both a reconciliation and a “sibling rivlary” with Cyclops/Havok and some touching moments with Wasp/Havok.

The nice character moments are distracting from few plot holes, since, plot-wise, we are left to assume that Red Onslaught just stands around in the ruins of the scene while the heroes wait nine hours for Iron Man to wake up and lead them again. (But since I guess he really just stands there the whole time the heroes fight the Sentinels it’s not too hard to imagine.)

Maybe that plot hole is a fault of the story/art, as there’s a nice transition from one timeframe to the other with a page of black panels. However, the setting appears perfectly the same in terms of background and color palette. It’s a bit narratively disconnected. The art also suffers from a lack of dramatic intensity. The entire tone of the action/dialogue is one of epic-ness, but the panels are relatively straightforward at the best of times, and taking certain layout choices for granted in the worst cases. For example, it’s a pretty dramatic movement for characters to be taken out by the Sentinels, but in fact they just stand/float there in a panel and glow blue. The convention is to at least have a beam of something coming from the villain in order for, say, Captain America to knock Iron Man away from it. And we never actually see the Sentinel trying to crush Iron Man, just this round thing that pushes him into the ground for a couple of pages.   

-Danny Wall

Grade

B

Conclusion

The extended fight scene continues, with a bit more of a fatalistic tone. The groundwork is laid for the series' big twist as the Scarlet Witch awkwardly refers to "a rotation of axis," Iron Man feels just as much like a supervillain than a hero, and Magneto arrives in an exciting last-page splash. Solid comicbook set pieces and storytelling, with some straightforward art, makes everything just shy of "classic" but is still pretty fun. Other Tidbits: -- Does this mean Genesis is not dead if he's in the heroes' hidey hole? -- There's a conspicuous lack of heroes from the assemblage that appeared last issue. I guess we can just assume they've all been taken out off-panel and/or between issues? If so, then why even have them show up in the first place? -- In the same way, the "cast" page should probably be re-visited. I don't think it's fair to list Sunfire or She-Hulk if they don't actually appear, and I'm not sure the Invisible Woman changed her codename to Iron Fist while we weren't looking.