The Story: Sometimes you don’t choose the SP//dr; it chooses you.
The Review: This is a great example of a “Edge of Spider-Verse” done right. There’s enough familiar spider-elements to make it “Spider” but enough of a twist to really fit the “Edge” part of it, making it one of the more alien “Verses” we’ve visited. And that’s cool.
Peni Parker is the hero here, but she defies a simple characterization. She’s at times described as a “teenage weapon,” a “Gene-Pop” celebrity, “speed-metal”/”hardcore”, “女性操縦士 (josei sōjūshi)/ Girl Pilot”, and… a vegetarian. It’s our second vaguely Japanese spider-hero (after Dr. Aaron Aikman’s version in issue #3) and this one is much more intriguing, hitting all the right notes to show just enough to be interesting and hiding just enough to keep things intriguing. She’s also a legacy hero, taking the Sp//dr identity from her father, and those familiar hero/Spider-Man tropes about family and responsibility show up through that.
Interestingly, there’s a second “hero” here, the spider itself, who acts in a kind of symbiotic way (and yes, it’s telling that the word “symbiote” could be used here). While the true nature of the spider, its origin, and its relationship to Peni isn’t explicit, it’s one of the most intriguing of those intriguing elements I’ve mentioned. What’s unfortunate is that the art has to struggle to include the spider in a meaningful way. It can be difficult to display layouts of things, and integrate such layouts together, when there is such a different size relationship. So too often the spider shows up in a postage stamp-size panel disconnected from the serial, or suddenly appears on Peni’s hand. Perhaps this contributes to an eerie, almost sci-fi thriller, aspect of the story, with this strange enigmatic spider on the fringes of the action and coming-of-age story.
In the context of the whole series, there seemed to be an ongoing threat of Morlun (the Morluns?) which is conspicuously absent here. Each progressive issue of this series seemed to have more and more of an escalated threat, but now with no Morlun at all, just a few Other-Spideys, the tension is completely gone. Peni just more or less shrugs and says “OK. Come on, strangers. Let’s go.” I suppose I shouldn’t complain because the rest of the story is allowed to breathe a bit as a consequence.
-Danny Wall
Grade
A
Conclusion
This Edge issue offers just as much of a distinct character, artistic vision, and unique twist on our formula as the better issues of the series. The visual style is of simple but shaky/vibrant lines and large panels that are supplemented by series of smaller ones. It's realism but with a tinge of sadness and of weirdness, presenting a world to the reader without having to hold him/her by the hand. Intriguing and satisfying, it creates a great new character but maybe could have been integrated into the ongoing storyline better.