I like using a critical approach to comicbook reviews that follows the “New Criticism” ideas– works of art are more or less entities of themselves that can be self-contained. It looks at the work-as-work, removed from context such as the creators’ points of view, personal issues, and zeitgeist. Other alternatives might be Deconstructionism, Postmodernism, or Structuralism. In other words, yes, I was an English major at one point in my life.

All of that to say, with so many contexts that gave rise to this comicbook, it’s difficult to separate the reading experience of Captain America & the Mighty Avengers from the moment of time it’s being read. After all, this book is a relaunch of The Mighty Avengers, features a repositioning of a key character into Captain America’s role, and is firmly planted in the events of Marvel’s concurrent publishing event, AXIS. Divorced from all of that, is the comicbook any good?

Yeah, it’s a decent read, in that light, because it hits every structural bit that would make a decent comicbook. The title character, Captain America, is firmly established, by pitting him against a small, random bit of crime and also against a more “classic” supervillain. He espouses his motivation in both private thoughts and through interaction, and all of that builds into the cliffhanger that promises to ratchet everything to the next level. The subplot features Luke Cage and Spider-Man, although it’s all through conversation, and this interaction is both a foil and a feature of the issues that Captain America is dealing with. You know, since Spider-Man can serve as a counterpoint here, having recently gone through an “inversion,” of sorts, into supervillainy when possessed by Doctor Octopus.

The main problem is one that continues from the previous series– by focusing on only one primary character, the series really fails to be a team book. The Avengers themselves only show up as holograms, discounting Cage’s appearances in the subplot. If this were Captain America’s solo book, that might be excusable, but I’m always hoping for that team dynamic. When I buy a box of Crackerjack, for example, I expect both caramel corn and peanuts and a toy surprise, after all.   

We do get a continuation of the signature look for this series, however, in that Ross seems to emulate the style of Greg Land from the Mighty Avengers. This means rendering a near-photographic likeness for each pose, including wide eyes and gaping smiles. But this also means it falls victim to a weird irony– the more it tries to hit a level of “realism,” the more it creates an “uncanny valley” that immediately distances the viewer. Also, it tends to be just close enough to real anatomy that it looks realistic, but then every so often there is a twisted pose or out-of-proportion body part that just shatters the illusion. And while it’s not as egregious, it is disappointing that figures are reduced largely to simply point a finger or raise a hand to indicate dialogue. It results in a stilted, staccato dialogue exchange, like all the characters are practicing some remedial acting class.

The sequences of panels, though, is very near superb. There’s a definite choreography of figures from panel to panel, and there’s never any breaking of the 180-Degree Rule, allowing the story to just flow, even when things are broken down like a five-panel sequence as the Captain throws the shield at a getaway car, along with four-panel sequence as the shield returns.

And that brings me back to the problem of context. It’s not a pleasant experience to watch Captain America remorselessly attack others, use excessive force, deny/delay services, use birds as increased surveillance, and overall essentially be the series’ villain. You can also see the overt symbolism of government overreach by the United States. We already had that in Avengers & X-Men: Axis…

Grade

C+

Conclusion

It's a solidly structured comicbook to be sure, but when the main protagonist is set up to be fundamentally unlikeable, that's a fundamental problem. Other Tidbits: -- Not enough attention is given to the Plunderer's sword, which is basically a light saber with a revolver as a hilt/pommel. That just so insane it has to be cool. Widening the layout of a few panels would have helped showcase this weird bit of coolness/oddity, as would have some token acknowledgement in the dialogue. -- Full disclosure: I never buy boxes of Crackerjack.