I’m happy to report on another enjoyable issue of Captain Marvel, full of great, expressive art, creative ideas, and plain-old, all-around fun. There’s still a few things going on that keep it just short of great, like a piece of sculpture that still has a few sharp edges that needed smoothing, but despite of that (or maybe even because of that) it’s quite charming.

It’s a complete story, absent of any subplot, and features a guest star who hasn’t been seen for some time– the space-faring Lila Cheney. There’s some rough exposition in the beginning, as the characters have to clunk their way through some artificial conflict and some out-of-left-field “loophole” explanation, both of which are pretty much wiped away in the space of one panel. It’s quite artificial in the first place, of course, that Lila’s dilemma is so perfect for Captain Marvel to solve (not to mention the sudden and artificial way Lila suddenly has a letter to deliver to her at our cliffhanger)… all of which are a few of the rough edges that I mentioned before.

Still, the roughest edge of all, and by far the most distracting, is the quirk of having the entire planet speak in rhyme. I know I’m not supposed to worry about xenolinguistics or something, and thankfully I can usually suspend disbelief all over the place with my sci-fi. The problem here is that it’s not so seamless. For example, rhyming is one thing, but rhythm is also important, and is usually an implied component. So when the characters’ dialogue doesn’t scan well, or is of varying lengths, or is started by one character and taken up by another (including being split across panels) the flow is thrown off, and the constraints of rhyme fall apart. I’ll give points for creativity, but if this is the challenge the writer sets for herself, she’s failed to stick the landing, and it’s all her own fault.    

But even with these rough patches, the script is quite clever. It takes a familiar, stock story and twists it a bit, has an opportunity for some action, and even implies some ethical dilemma if Captain Marvel should involve herself with this situation at all (I can hear the phrase “Prime Directive” coming from some circles.) The situation is resolved in a simple way, however, and I suppose there is potential to update Tic’s Marvel Handbook entry, but if I have to guess, it’s more likely to end up potential for a “Abandoned and Forsaked” column at CBR.

Ahem. Which reminds me, can I just say again how much I hate Tic? The character is barely distinctive at all, and although she plays a key point to the resolution of the story here, it’s really quite pointless. It doesn’t change her, since she’s such a cypher to begin with, and because it’s likely we’ll never see this planet again, there’s no stake to her decision. Could it be that this is actually a culmination of her sort-of Cinderella Story? She rose from a lowly station on a backwater planet to become princess on another? It’s forced and arbitrary as hell, but if she stays out of subsequent issues, I’ll let it slide.   

The real selling point, of course, is the artwork. Lopez and Loughridge are a winning combination here, and Lopez goes wild with the opportunity for a planet full of crazy costume design. From the first appearance of this planet, with alien architecture and plantlife, to glam-rock inspired wedding guests, it’s pure visual stimuli from start to finish. The expressions, too, are a key feature, as characters enhance the reading through their exaggerated emoting. I love the bits of background action, too, like the queen mother’s gown with floating rocks or the device the prince uses to create a facial tattoo. These background moments don’t distract from our main focus, thanks to judicious panel layout by Lopez and key color framing by Loughridge.

Overall, I’d say that Captain Marvel has found a groove of its own– the tone, artwork, and ideas as presented here give the book a distinct flavor. It’s a signature quality and distinctive feel– it’s a “Captain Marvel book.”

-Danny Wall

Grade

B

Conclusion

On a creative level it's lots of fun-- A fairy tale, twisted, done-in-one. While story flows in fits and starts, Its beauty lies within the art. "No more rhyming now, I mean it!" "Anybody want a peanut?"