If you know about Hitchcock’s Café Bomb-under-the-Table, you’ll remember it’s a storytelling device that ensures an audience’s suspense by revealing a bomb to the audience but keeping the actual characters unaware. It’s taken us twenty issues of All-New X-Factor, but at last the bomb is revealed– the true nature of Serval Industries, the secrets of its founder Harrison Snow and his reasons for creating a team of mutants…. just in time for the final issue of the series? In other words, if this issue was meant to be full of intrigue, then imagine how much suspense and intrigue we could have had if these revelations where there from the very beginning. Ah, well.
As an issue in and of itself, it’s well-crafted enough, but surprisingly lacking in direct action. Snow is truly the featured character, which follows up on how he was so featured in the previous issue, but largely it’s all confined to dialogue in a boardroom. Also unfortunate, the interaction is based on a character from another series, Spider-Man 2099, and ties into that character’s driving motivation of his own book, the destruction of Alchemax. Also furtherly unfortunate? A big reveal about the “future” is another character, unnamed but memorable if you remember other works by Peter David, the Maestro. All in all, the revelations about Serval Industries may be directly proportional to your feelings about the oeuvre of Peter David in general. If you happen to be outside that circle, you may find this issue disappointing, particularly since anything offered in this issue cannot be followed up.
The more intriguing, or rather, the more innovative, parts to this issue is the, ahem, climax of the running subplot of Danger’s existential dilemma. The setting, again, is quite underwhelming– some ill-defined space in X-Factor’s jet, which still allows for characters to mill around, make sandwiches, or float mid-air. Even though Serval has teleporters. Anyway. The interaction between Danger and Warlock isn’t born out of anything new– robots are pretty much always used to explore themes of identity and “humanity,” after all– but exploring it through questions about relationships and sex feels new, here. There’s implications about what relationships mean, about what “souls” are, or even fundamentally about what sex is. Even when such implications can be a bit uncomfortable.
The art is shared between the regular artist Carmine Di Giandomenico and Will Sliney, or perhaps the art is assisted by Sliney, as the style is similar but the finishes feel more flat, the layouts and figures less dynamic. The clear stamp of Di Giadomenico includes the crazed expressions of Cypher, an emotive Warlock, and the dynamic panel display when Danger and Warlock consummate their connection. Unfortunately, that’s too far and few between, as the remainder of the book is essentially talking heads with characters having really nothing to do to “act” except more or less looking at one another for panels at a time.
Frankly, in the context of the series overall, it never really felt like All-New X-Factor got off the ground. There’s some teasing about being something new, as the title suggests, but in fact nearly every storyline in the twenty issues were consumed with the past, specifically the way they all centered on family relationships in one way or another. It’s only in this issue that we finally get the culmination of some things that was actually presented as innovative– both the Serval Industries motivation and Danger’s identity search. I appreciate X-Factor’s use of second or third-string characters, but they never seemed pushed to the edge that we might expect, missing out on giving the series a feeling of raised stakes. Instead of momentum, we got maintenance. Instead of spinning into new directions, we got spun wheels.
Grade
C+
Conclusion
All-New X-Factor presents us with too new, but too late. Characters get to stand around in a jet plane or in a boardroom, talking to one another and hinting at things that could be. Nothing's really changed, and the arcs of pretty much every character who's not Danger seems to be no better, or worse, off than when he or she started. I'm critical because I care-- X-Factor has always had extremely well-drawn characters (well, narratively, I mean, albeit with dynamic art) but it would be satisfying to see more of them "win" once all is said in done, and that opportunity seems to have never been realized.