When there’s nothing to do but wait for a superheroic rescue, it makes for a nice framing device to share stories about alternate visions of Squirrel Girl. It’s like Rashomon, but just not as Kurosawa-y.

This issue succeeds in its humor far more than the previous ones— it not only embraces its parody but squeezes it all up in a huge bear (squirrel?) hug, never letting go while chanting something about George.   

The art celebrates these framed stories, shifting as appropriate to provide parody for Silver-Agey goofiness, 90s-era confusion, and Aughts-style ultimate edginess. Blink and you’ll miss some takes on comic strip funnies and Milleresque grit as well. The styles are well-chosen, with cartoony versions of Squirrel Girl’s original Ditko design presented in complete earnestness and yet becoming parody when side-by-side the way S.G. sports a take on the Scarlet Spider’s cut-off sweatshirt. Honestly, there are so many great tidbits along the way that it’s impossible to call attention to them all in this review.

The only downside here is the claustrophobia that results from so much being crammed in. Those Miller-like Dark Squirrel panels, for example, deserve more than two panels (one of which is overlapped by an inset panel!), and there’s a Squirrel Girl/MODOK mashup that is hilarious but lost in visual confusion. Frustratingly, too many times the dialogue balloons have to cover up to much of what should be prominent. The non-split scene with the hostages “breathe” better because there’s more room for it, but then that results in large areas of indistinct backgrounds in some places, and strange juxtaposition of background action in others. The colors do their best to provide some gradient and texture, but it’s hard to cram so much and make it feel balanced, visually, from page to page.

The verbal humor is just as spot-on as the visuals, being a great companion to it all. There’s a lot of puns and situational humor from the various scenarios; one my favorites being the ludicrous amount of abbreviations in Squirrel G.I.R.L.’s world. What’s even better is the banter in-between the framing stories, so when Nancy cuts one off, it blends right into the framed story seamlessly. So, too, are the characters that make up the hostages. They all have individual looks as well as personality quirks, making them more than generic ciphers and just as entertaining as the stories they tell. Nancy herself becomes more than an acerbic roommate; she is rounding out herself to be just as distinct a min character as the titular hero.

Some plot logic has to be sacrificed for all this humor to work, of course, which is a bit of a downside as well. We’re told these are hostages, of course, without actually seeing the hostage situation nor the reason for these people to be collected. Were they tourists? Where they brought here as prisoners? It doesn’t matter to the parodies being told, and would cramp an already-crammed story, but it does feel like something is missing. The other bit of story logic is when these “everyday” citizens display knowledge of the Marvel universe that the readers definitely know but is doubtful that an average Joe/Jane would. I mean, is it a coincidence that a random citizen can name-drop a 2099 reference, or that another would know the basic plot set-up of Spider-Man’s Clone Saga? This is a feature of these types of stories, so it’s best not to overthink it, but still….        

As an aside, I wish I had whatever Twitter-account-parody the characters are using for the first-page recap, but only so I can post a meme pic proudly declaring “Too Long Didn’t Read!”

Grade

A

Conclusion

It’s everything you want a Marvel humor book to be. The only criticism is that it’s almost too much of everything, to the point of some things getting lost. Just keep re-reading it, though, and you’ll not only get them all but have a great time doing it.