So, after Everything dies, the universe exists as only Battleworld, and this issue goes into detail to provide some narrative world-building, in the true sense of the word. Dr. Doom is at its center, politically and religiously, but what he truly thinks about this and how things begin to emerge and to threaten this is where the story really lies.
The issue starts with a new point-of-view character as he begins his recruitment in the Thor Corps, and readers are taken for a ride-along as he begins “walking his beat” alongside the Old Thor. Such a role has been sorely needed for many key points of this epic, building from the pages of the Avengers but somehow always existing on a surface level, and this simple device helps to personalize the story and setting. A ton of information needs to be exposited, and a new character in a new role is a way to re-familiarize ourselves with these familiar-but-not collection of mini-worlds, remixed to indulge in fan favortie-spotting.
The political intrigue between these worlds takes the focus when Dr. Doom appears. The characters act out their new roles in surprising ways, a feature of these stories that fans love. There’s something surprising and intriguing seeing characters like Jamie Braddock and a royal family of Captain Britain and Meggan along with name-dropped cameos of the Goblin Queen (Madeline Pryor from Inferno) and villains from the Age of Apocalypse. Surprises, sure, but they are born from the remixing of nostalgia and classic favorites. I, for one, find a lot of fun in recognizing things, and it makes me long for those days I used to run Marvel Encyclopedia-type websites. I’ll leave the criticism as to whether this is new-reader friendly or not to actual new readers.
Now, if all the intrigue feels like Game of Thrones, it might also be because there’s something called The Wall that’s been guarded by generations and holds back undead creatures from invading the other lands. It might also be because Game of Thrones has somehow become a litmus test for dramatic storytelling these days. Didn’t they say also say this about the Inhumanity event last year? And what was that about remixes again?
As much as I appreciate the point-of-view character, he is not presented in a way for the readers to really empathize with. He’s not a fully-formed character that we emotionally resonate with. In fact, he’s likely just another citizen of Battleworld that’s not necessarily important to the story or for our pathos. I would have preferred picking up with some of the characters who were lead characters aboard the lifeboat in the first issue. Now, they are completely absent as we take our ride-along tour. The stakes feel somewhat lessened, accordingly.
It’s also not clear why, narratively, these worlds are chosen for Battleworld. Some of the worlds mentioned (like Inferno or Spider-Island or Planet Hulk) are in fact the same Marvel Earth in the first place, so is Battleworld different planets/different Earths or are they pieces of the same Earth from different times? The in-universe explanation for this remains to be seen.
Similarly, it seems weird that Mr. Sinister and the world of the Captain Britain Corps become the characters and worlds spotlighted here. These guys were never any kind of blip on any kind of radar for the past three years of building up to Secret Wars, so their appearance seems out of place. Especially Jamie Braddock, a character who hasn’t been depicted in a comicbook panel for over 25 years. (And who, incidentally, has mutant reality-bending powers that seems like they could have come into play for this kind of reality-bent story.)
Instead, Doom is the focal point for this issue. I dare say it’s easy to see this as a Dr. Doom comicbook overall. I mean, he’s certainly shown to us and told to us as if he is a hero, nay even a god of this world’s legend. And actually he’s doing a pretty good job of it; at least in the sense that the Battleworld does appear to be running smoothly, despite some other villains (Sinister, Braddock) that are trying to be petty and selfish. Why, exactly, would these antagonists have cause to rebel, except for some generic criminality?
The art here is a dramatic improvement from the first issue. Here, the strength of the art makes each panel a showpiece— still frames that capture the key drama of any given moment. It works well for this kind of pacing. Whereas the last issue was more kinetic and action-based, this issue is meant to pause and look around as much as possible. The backgrounds and variety of environments come across clear and distinct, and the colors give us a variety of atmospheres to enhance each world. Appropriately, perhaps, as the world itself is just as important as the characters within it.
The story also allows for fewer characters to be depicted on any given page, and thus each character is given (and demands) more attention. The expressions are much more varied, as well, including some dynamic poses and costume choices. All the characters are sexy and melodramatic, appropriately larger than life. The painterly aspect of the art also helps, and it all raises it to a higher level. It helps remind us that this is truly an epic.
Grade
B
Conclusion
Despite some questionable plot-logic (random character appearances, point-of-views that are merely ciphers, absence of key characters) this issue presents a pretty convincing picture of Battleworld and how it fits together. Dr. Doom is set to become our protagonist, and a heavy head wears the crown. The excitement comes the cameos of the fan-favorite events and alternate stories over the years, even if it’s largely all just window dressing (albeit beautifully rendered window dressing, even moreso than the first issue.) If you like a Dr. Doom story as a character study, this will be ranked among the best, but it will be hard to find any characters with which to root for, let alone emotionally resonate.