Is it a gimmick that the comic features an all-star roster of Marvel Comics superheroic women? Maybe, and that just as good a reason as any to tune into this comicbook. Teen teams, mutant teams, Earth’s mightiest heroes, a bunch of people all named Robin… it’s an excuse to gather all our favorites in one place and see how they bounce off each other.
Here? Turns out they all work together pretty well. Until someone throws a giant shark over a wall which causes problems for everybody.
The story serves as a nice set-up as a bunch of heroes begin to realize that “something is rotten in the state of Denmark,” or Arcadia/Battleworld, whichever. The cliffhanger offers two separate tilts to the status quo, and She-Hulk, the Baroness of this land, is poised to make some heroic choices in the coming issues.
As with many of these kinds of stories, however, there really isn’t a point of view character, in the sense that we readers are moved to empathize with her. Instead, a variety of character who are already fully-formed are paraded around giving readers a glimpse of life-in-progress. Ms. America seems to display the attitude that we readers want to identify with, but she’s removed from the board almost immediately, and she seems to have deep connections with both Loki and Sister Grimm, but we just have to just take for granted.
A book such as this sometimes has to rely a lot on readers’ preconceived vision for the characters, so if we know Ms. America from previous comics it’s easier to see her fit this role, and to see Loki in a female iteration isn’t so surprising if we remember this version of her from a couple years ago. I, for one, love the fun of recognizing cameos of the likes of Crystal and Meggan, Captain Marvel, and Luke Cage/Jessica Jones, and also in seeing the most classic version of all the costumes. You’d (almost) forgive the fact that Dazzler is shown being able to fly, when she’s also sporting her original outfit’s roller skates.
That said, only two or three characters really get the majority of the lines; despite Pixie being on nearly every page, she literally has one balloon: “Oh, America, Nooo…” Rogue’s present only from the neck down, in the background of one panel. Where exactly did she come from, then? So, based on who’s *actually* involved in the plot, should this really be titled “A-Force,” or just “She-Hulk and Sister Grimm?”
The setting and figure-work, though, is simply amazing, as is the coloring, particularly in the landscape. The series starts with a series of thin panels which opens to a lovely double-page spread of a break-taking view of the city. The action against the monster shark is dynamic and the poses of the figures is great.
What’s really a problem is some of the storytelling. How, exactly, did Dazzler stop a giant monster shark? She talks about her powers, then the shark is above the water (leaping?) and looking like he’s throwing up purple energy, then Dazzler does a brokeback twist and tells the shark to “sing,” and something around the shark goes “B-oooM” and the creature is… thrown? exploded? knocked back? to lands in a public square. And what, exactly, does Sam Wilson of the Thors do? He appears (with SO MANY wings. Just so many) in a CRSSSSHH of light, tells Ms. America she’s in trouble, and then… another CRSSSSHH? But she’s not actually taken, because two pages later she’s surrounded by her friends, and THEN there’s a bunch of non-Sam Wilson Thors and more light, and there’s nothing left but a smoking jacket that someone was apparently holding onto? (Not a smoking-jacket jacket, but a jacket with smoke coming off of it.)
Which brings up the question about what, exactly, does A-Force do anyway? They “patrol” borders, but they can’t cross them, nor can they police anything if that’s what Thor Corps are supposed to do. I guess there are villains, since we are told on page one that “heroes, and villains” are part of this island, but does that mean they are are also a part of the team, like Loki? Ms. America’s punishment is to guard the Shield, but isn’t that what A-Force is kind of doing, already?
I am happy to see She-Hulk as such a headliner, but just to go on record, I’ll give this book an automatic A+ if the writers could feature one of my favorite obscure villains, Ruby Thursday.
Grade
B
Conclusion
She-Hulk makes a commanding leader for the heroes of A-Force, although before Ms. America can become the break-out star, she’s sidelined. Whether or not you think it’s a gimmick to have an all-female hero team, there better be more opportunities for a truly ensemble cast for this book to live up to such a promise. That, and some confusing visual sequences, makes the reading experience more uneven than it deserves to be, but the book remains an intriguing and worthwhile addition to the Secret Wars line-up.