While most of Secret Wars/Battleworld seems like an exercise to exploit nostalgia, Where Monsters Dwell stands out as something that could be genuinely new, and that felt intriguing. Or, to be more precise, most of the Battleworld titles are built around specific and beloved storylines from Marvel Comics within the last 20 years. This comic, however, seems to take its cue from the pulp-era genre in a more general way, and references a Marvel comic from 1970. Doesn’t that sound awesome?

True to form, what we get is the introduction of our two main characters and the last few pages presents their predicament, being trapped in one of those “land that time forgot” places. So maybe it’s not really new after all.

Now, I usually try to review any comic for what it *is,* as I don’t really hold much stock in criticism that brings down a book simply because of what it *isn’t.* That said, I want to formally register my disappointment that we don’t get any classic monsters appearing in the first issue, which is what I was expecting from such a title. No Gigantus? Orrgo? Googam son of Goom? This was the same series that debuted Fin Fang Foom and Groot back in the day, you realize. And it may be that we will get some of these classic monsters in the coming issues, but for now what the comic *is* is a pretty straightforward pulp-style adventure story.

The first four pages (i.e. two or three too many) are devoted to a drawn-out scene that establishes our hero Karl Kaufman as… well, as a jerk. The lady he leaves behind wrings out some very heavy-handed melodrama, thanks to some overwrought dialogue that verges almost on parody. I usually prefer my heroes a bit more … heroic. Perhaps it will get there, but that means it’s all pretty much a set up for all the typical plot points we expect of such stories along the path to Where Tropes Dwell. The last page even has the guy standing with his arm against the dino’s leg as if to say “What? He’s right behind me, isn’t he?” 

Disappointedly, that’s pretty much the whole level of the plot here. There’s no mention whatsoever about Battleworld or the state of the Secret Wars world— apparently either all of the “Far East” got lumped together in a small nation on the side of the Battleglobe or this comic takes place/was written in the 1940s. That makes the comic just a straightforward pulp adventure, so, uhm, well. That’s okay, I guess.

The art is very lush and tries to set the comic apart from being truly mediocre. The colors in particular are quite nice and painterly, with lavish shading and a bold use of rendered highlights. The characters and the settings are well-realized, with wonderful acting and facial expressions. The dinosaurs are quite well drawn, although we really only get about three pages worth. Even a panel as simple as the figures running from their downed plane with alligator-like eyeballs peeking through the surface in the foreground is nearly perfect.

Despite the loveliness of the art, the reading experience was still a bit empty.

Grade

C+

Conclusion

With too many one-note characters in stock situations, the comic presents a nice little pulp adventure, but that’s pretty much about it. Thankfully, the art and colors are amazing to look at. But even with awesome art, the story can’t really distinguish itself beyond familiar beats with an unlikeable hero.