I had an outline prepped for this review that, in one of those unfortunate moments of distraction, I accidentally deleted. As any of you who’ve pulled this trick knows, it’s the kind of mistake that makes you question whether it’s worth it to start over. Obviously, I decided it was, and not just because I’ll be damned before I not finish what I started. The Wicked + The Divine, despite its indulgences, is a compelling story that has something more to tell us than it’s saying.

On the surface, the story is a textbook whodunit, albeit with a more fantastic range of suspects and more complicated mystery than usual. None of this changes Laura’s role in sussing out each character’s possible motivations for having Luci killed. Even though the Pantheon had some big talk about policing themselves in #4, so far the only god who’s put himself out there is Inanna, and only in an advisory capacity. For better or worse, Laura’s the only detective we’ve got.

The “better” part of that equation is she’s now firmly entrenched in the Pantheon life, and thus in a better position than most detectives to get up close and personal with the suspects. Better yet, she’s actually in the uncommon position of being in most of their good graces. You’d think with Luci gone, they’d have no use for Laura, but there’s Baal getting kind of saucy (“So, how’s Satan’s little helper?”) when he spots her at Fantheon and the Morrigan and Baphomet—Baphomet, of all gods!—inviting her to join them for booze and karaoke.

That leads us to the “worse” of Laura’s investigative role, which is whether she can maintain her objectivity as she gets in even deeper with literally her idols. Right now, she’s doing pretty well. She’s amazingly brusque with Baal, her former crush, and openly hostile towards Woden. But she starts the same way with Baph and all it takes is a bit of somewhat ambiguous sympathy (“I can’t say I care, but I do understand.”) with the sunglasses off to get him into her good graces again.

Still, we’re finally getting to see the personal side of these gods, the way they think and act when not before the worshipful masses. For some, like Woden, we even get something of their motivations. He’s proof that even when you’re a god, there’s always something more to wish for. With each issue, the Pantheon’s two-year lifespan looms larger in the story, a deadline that drives all of them to a certain extent. It’s the reason for Woden’s disregard for common decency and the truth and for Baph’s prickishness (“It’s my own pre-emptive revenge, born of jealousy at everyone else’s amazing continuing-to-breath-in-two-years’-time power.”). Makes you wonder why the Recurrence would allow gods to walk on Earth yet deprive them of their most coveted feature, their immortality.

Even without eternal life, godhood is an attractive position to be in, so much so that it spawns an urban legend, really a desperate fairy tale, that killing a god bestows the killer with the victim’s power. Kerry, the former Brunnhilde and ex-Valkyrie, lusts so much for the power she once had that she’s willing to abandon discretion, dignity, and her own life to get it back. This sets up a sad dichotomy between the Pantheon and their followers. The former envy the extra time they might have had to live; the latter would risk a relatively brief life for the power they’d get in exchange.

It’s been a while since McKelvie’s done a radical designer page as he often used to do on Young Avengers, but Luci’s death has done something to spark his creative ambition as we see several brilliant art choices in this issue alone. The map of Fantheon is not only engrossing in its level of detail,* but a clever way to convey Laura’s day of activity, her internal reactions, and the nature of the setting all at the same time. Notice, too, that McKelvie plunges the crowds into featureless gray figures. Sure, this could be a way to spare him from having to draw hundreds of individual faces, but I’d like to think it’s an artistic way of showing how the gods see the rest of humanity, which is significant because Laura sees them the same way.

Some Musings:

– I adore the punny vendor names. As a California, I’m particularly tickled by “Inanna and Out Burgers,” although “Bap-O-Meat” has a lovely ring to it.

Grade

A-

Conclusion

The more intimate we become with the characters, the more complex and revealing they seem, shifting us from the reality TV distance of previous issues.