
By: Charles Soule (story), Alberto Ponticelli (pencils), Stefano Landini (inks), Danny Vozzo (colors)
The Story: Without your memories, you might as well be dead.
The Review: The interesting thing you notice after seeing three Soule works in a row is the flexibility of his style. He takes a different approach to exploring the villain at the center of each issue, from pacing to tone and even to choice of narrator. If you ask me, the variations seem to depend on the comfort level Soule has with the character, which unsurprisingly affects how successful the resulting products are, too.
Just look at the self-narrated Lex Luthor, which gave us a very intimate and rich portrait of the eponymous mastermind. Compare that to Arcane, which clearly had less insight to give us regarding the ex-avatar and required some narrative assistance from another character altogether. Now, consider Black Hand, the most distant of the three issues with its omniscient narrator. With that kind of perspective, you should get more hard information about the undead Lantern than either Luthor or Arcane, but Hand proves the most obtuse of them all.
There’s really no substance of note here, not for the fresh-faced reader or for the longtime fan. Soule offers no glimpse into Hand’s past or how he fits into the future of Forever Evil or the Green Lantern mythos or anything else. At best, he lays out one clear goal for himself, which is disappointingly the same one he’s always had: destroy his archnemesis. You don’t get any more traditional villainy than that, even if the latest plan involves a touch more twistedness than usual.
I’m not sure there’s much to look at in regards to Hand’s personality either. Usually, when you have a scenario where a character has lost his memories, it’s an opportunity to expose the bottom line of the character, to see what kind of person he is when he’s just a blank slate without the imprint of environment or upbringing. But throughout the issue, Hand is so distracted by the absence and confusion of his memories that you don’t really get much out of him. It’s obvious that, like Arcane, he has an obsession with death, though his runs a little deeper. He doesn’t see his own depravity at all; he only sees the beauty in death.
It’s a testament to Soule’s skill as a storyteller that despite a dearth of new material, he still manages to deliver an engaging story for as long as it lasts. He’s really one of the most effective set-up builders I’ve ever read, with an uncanny ability to establish the setting and players in a short amount of time. In just a page or two, you become familiar with the lives and traits of even the most shortlived characters: two morgue handlers musing over the morbidity of their work;* a whiny prisonmate shouting for attention; and a senior police officer having an “I told you so” moment when his anti-zombie trainings finally come to fruition.*
Ponticelli’s art is a love-it-or-hate-it kind of work, but it’s pretty well applied here. Since he tends to render characters such that they look bedraggled and emaciated anyway, an issue full of ambling cadavers seems like a perfect fit. Another plus to Ponticelli’s work is even though it’s far from what’s conventionally attractive, it’s also never silly, cartoonish, or exaggerated. It’s that Vertigo quality where it might not look very pleasant, but at least you can still take it seriously.
Conclusion: A credible read, but one that doesn’t leave you with much once you set it down.
Grade: C+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * According to one of them, the number one rule of the dead-people business is: “Don’t think too much.” Sound advice.
* And can I just say that many a zombie apocalypse could have prevented with that kind of preparation? A salute to that prudent officer, I say!
Grade
Conclusion