By: Charles Soule (story), Andrei Bressan (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)

The Story: It only takes a single seed to grow a forest—and piss off a plant god.

The Review: Creating new villains is a tricky business.  Even though the point is to give the hero someone to fight, a villain can’t exist solely for that purpose—or they can, but you wouldn’t be able to use them for more than one issue.  And when you do add some extra motivation, you have to be careful about making them too cliché or simplistic.  Criminals who are greedy, power-hungry, or just plain crazy don’t provide a lot of analytical meat to chew on.

Having seen Soule delve into the hearts, minds, and lives of three completely different villains last month, each from a different sphere of influence (the supernatural, the cosmic, and the urban professional), it’s safe to say that he has a knack for finding the thing that makes an antagonist worth your attention.  It’s not enough to make a villain evil; that just makes them predictable.  Soule knows that it’s each villain’s specific set of values that drives them to make different choices in different circumstances, and that in turn is what makes them compelling.

Seeder is already interesting to begin with because his actions place Swamp Thing in the uncomfortable position of acting as the bad guy to a lot of innocent people.  But even more interesting is an absence of animosity towards our hero (at least at first).  Though displeased to see his work undone, he refuses to overrule his counterpart’s work, even when begged by his intended beneficiaries.  He freely acknowledges himself as a subordinate to the Green’s avatar, adding a nice complication to the usual hero-villain conflict.

In one respect, Soule gives us a more credible portrait of Seeder in this issue than Swamp Thing himself.  Between the distress and rage he expresses when threatened with having his powers removed, as well as a reminder of the bargain he struck with the Parliament of Trees back in Swamp Thing Annual #1,* Seeder’s obsession with the Green is clear.  At the same time, he’s also sensitive and rational, and it’s clear Alec’s scolding about the costs of using the Green for philanthropic purposes has an effect on him.

But this wouldn’t be a proper comic if Seeder didn’t spur some tension somehow, so Soule has Alec shoot himself in the foot by a sudden display of ego.  For someone who’s new to his powers himself, Alec proves surprisingly insensitive to Seeder’s experimental accidents.  This rush of cockiness comes from makes his subsequent near-defeat at Seeder’s hands all the more deserved.  Soule is perhaps upturning two years’ worth of issues emphasizing Alec’s destiny as avatar, which Alec himself has now taken for granted.  Seeder’s existence is intended to challenge Alec’s complacency and remind him where the Parliament’s loyalties truly lie (“We believe it is in the interest of the Green to see which of you would be the stronger avatar…”).  Alec is understandably pissed by this turn of events, which brings out his humanity even further.

Fortunately, just as he encounters his newest archrival, Alec gains a new pal to even things out a bit.  Despite a sound defeat at Seeder’s hands last issue, Capucine proves quite useful when the chips are down even without a set of powers.  Offering her protective services in exchange for Swamp Thing’s seems like a pretty fair deal.  At least she has a dry sense of humor to liven things up for Alec once in a while.  Though centuries old, she’s pretty canny about awkward relationship euphemisms: “A…friend.  You wish me to live in your old lover’s house?”

Yanick Paquette left a deep impact on this series, which reveals itself with the way every artist that’s come onto this book since has tried to emulate his elaborate panel designs, with varying degrees of success.  Bressan wisely doesn’t spend too much time doing this—his few attempts look obligatory and forced, anyway—and instead sticks to his strengths: well-formed figures, a good sense of detailing and texture, and a decent flair for action (who’d ever have expected a head-kick move in Swamp Thing?).  With Wilson’s rich colors, Bressan delivers a respectable fill-in job.

Conclusion: A convincing set-up of enmity between our hero and villain, though it requires a slightly out-of-character moment from Swamp Thing.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Pretty impressive of Soule to pick up on that detail, which we all forgot about in the wake of Rotworld.  And pretty impressive of Scott Snyder for putting in that detail for future pick-up.

Grade

Conclusion